Federal appeals court: Hate Crimes Act does not prohibit anti-gay speech – LGBTQ Nation

Published August 3, 2012 by Tjchase

Federal appeals court: Hate Crimes Act does not prohibit anti-gay speech

By Brody Levesque

CINCINNATI, Ohio — A federal appeals court on Thursday rejected a lawsuit brought by three Michigan pastors challenging the constitutionality of the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act.

The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit ruled the Act — which imposes harsher punishments for individuals who commit violent acts on individuals due to their sexual orientation — was constitutional, and did not suppress anti-gay speech.

The suit was first filed in February 2010 by the conservative Thomas More Law Center, four months after President Barack Obama signed the legislation into law in October 2009.

Plaintiffs Gary Glenn, head of the American Family Association of Michigan, and pastors Levon Yuille, René B. Ouellette and James Combs had argued the law would lead to their criminal prosecution for expressing anti-gay religious beliefs, in violation of the First Amendment.

In the filing, the plaintiffs cited bible passages and quoted from novelist George Orwell’s “Animal Farm,” claiming the Shepard-Byrd Act treated certain individuals “more equal than others,” and said that the intent of the act was to “eradicate religious beliefs opposing the homosexual agenda.”

In their ruling today, the Court said that the plaintiffs had “not alleged any actual intent” to cause bodily injury to any gay individuals, and pointed out that the pastors explicitly denounced “crimes of violence perpetrated against innocent individuals.”

The Hate Crimes Act, the appeals court ruled, “does not prohibit Plaintiffs’ proposed course of speech” and said they “can’t quite pinpoint what it is they want to say that could subject them to prosecution under the Hate Crimes Act.”

The court acknowledged that should the plaintiffs, all pastors, quote the biblical passage Leviticus 20:13, which calls for men who have sex with one another to be put to death, “they have not alleged any intention to do more than merely quote it,” which is not unlawful under the provisions of the Shepard-Bryd Act.

“If the Hate Crimes Act prohibits only willfully causing bodily injury and Plaintiffs are not planning to willfully injure anybody, then what is their complaint? Plaintiffs answer that they fear wrongful prosecution and conviction under the Act. Not only is that fear misplaced, it’s inadequate to generate a case or controversy the federal courts can hear,” the appeals court ruled.

Glenn did not respond to a request from LGBTQ Nation for comment on today’s ruling.

via Federal appeals court: Hate Crimes Act does not prohibit anti-gay speech – LGBTQ Nation.


2 comments on “Federal appeals court: Hate Crimes Act does not prohibit anti-gay speech – LGBTQ Nation

  • hi!,I really like your writing so so much! share we communicate more approximately your post on AOL? I require a specialist on this house to unravel my problem. Maybe that is you! Having a look ahead to see you.

  • Leave a Reply

    Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s

    WordPress.com Apps

    Apps for any screen

    David Chase

    Author of "The Usui Reiki Handbook: A Course in Reiki Healing"

    Ajah Dharma

    om... may the great spirit bless you

    What a Witch

    I am not nice, but I am honest and that is more important.

    Witches Of The Craft®

    "Witchcraft For The 21st Century"

    RealityShifters Blog

    Live your best possible life. How good can it get?

    Dear Cis People

    The ramblings of a non-binary Latino.


    The realms of Spirit, Breath, Life ~ Shamanic Endeavors

    Stephanie Nicole

    Righteous Health

    Church of the Cosmos : Temple of Light


    UMHS Gender Services

    comprehensive gender services program for gender variant people and their families


    Real conspiracies - all original content

    Mystery of the Iniquity

    Truth is inspiring, it is guarded by GOD, and will triumph over all opposition!


    Quality gay-shaded & m/m stories, articles & art

    Josh Derke for State Representative

    Democrat for Michigan's 93rd House (2014)


    Just another WordPress.com site

    Edge Induced Cohesion

    A Historian's Eye View of the World

    HandyBob's Blog

    Making off grid RV electrical systems work

    The Journey

    This WordPress.com site is the cat’s pajamas

    Daily Queer News

    LGBTI News and Politics

    evoL =

    Allies for equality.

    current events

    news of the day

    Mr. Moon's Meditation Chamber

    The Official Blog of Hip Hop Artist Tony Moon

    Different People

    Being gay with a mental illness(Bipolar) is a HUGE task to undertake!

    The Catbox

    Musings on modern Druidry in the UK

    The LGBT community and the journey ahead

    Being Gay is not a choice, we are born that way



    News and reviews

    sharing with others

    The Dream Faire

    Enchanted Jewelry Designs & Magical Creations by ♥Kat

    %d bloggers like this: