BREAKING: Judge Rules DOMA Unconstitutional in Pedersen Case | Advocate.com

Published August 2, 2012 by Tjchase

DOMA Ruled Unconstitutional In Yet Another Case

In a blockbuster 104-page opinion, a Connecticut federal judge appointed by George W. Bush dealt another blow to the Defense of Marriage Act being defended by House Republicans.

BY JULIE BOLCER

JULY 31 2012 2:03 PM ET UPDATED: JULY 31 2012 5:33 PM ET

620

Joanne Pedersen and Ann Meitzen

A federal judge in Connecticut has ruled against the Defense of Marriage Act in a challenge brought by married same-sex couples.

Judge Vanessa Bryant, a George W. Bush appointee, ruled that the Section 3 of the 1996 law, which prohibits the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages, violates equal protection guarantees. The suit, Pedersen et al v. Office of Personnel Management et al, was brought by six couples and one widower in Connecticut, New Hampshire and Vermont who were denied federal benefits because they were legally married to a spouse of the same sex.

In a striking opinion that exceeded 100 pages, Judge Bryant concluded that, “having considered the purported rational bases proffered by both BLAG and Congress and concluded that such objectives bear no rational relationship to Section 3 of DOMA as a legislative scheme, the Court finds that no conceivable rational basis exists for the provision. The provision therefore violates the equal protection principles incorporated in the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution.”

Gay and Lesbian Advocates and Defenders is representing the plaintiffs, while the House Republican-controlled Bipartisan Legal Advisory Group (BLAG) has intervened to defend DOMA since the Obama administration announced it would no longer defend the law last year.

“Judge Bryant’s ruling is very clear: married people are married and should be treated as such by the federal government. There is no legitimate basis for DOMA’s broad disrespect of the marriages of same-sex couples,” said Mary L. Bonauto, GLAD’s Civil Rights Project Director, in a statement. “We are very pleased that the Court recognized that DOMA’s creation of second-class marriages harms our clients who simply seek the same opportunities to care and provide for each other and for their children that other families enjoy.”

Earlier this month, Judge Bryant cited the “public interest” in denying a request from BLAG to halt proceedings in the Pedersen case. The House Republicans argued that similar issues were under consideration in the case, Windsor v. United States. A federal judge in New York ruled DOMA unconstitutional in that case last month. Windsor is now on an expedited appeal schedule in the Second Circuit, and the plaintiff has also asked the Supreme Court to hear the case.

The Pedersen case, filed in November 2010, includes lead plaintiffs Joanne Pedersen and her spouse, Ann Meitzen. Pedersen, a federal retiree, is not allowed to cover Meitzen on her health insurance, which results in her spouse having to use more than 50% of her Social Security benefits to pay for her own health care benefits.

The grandmothers celebrated what the decision could mean for their lives and other same-sex couples during a conference call with reporters.

“I’m on cloud nine. I’m thrilled with the decision,” said Pedersen. “I’m looking forward to the next step, but for right now, I’m on top of the world.”

“It really took me surprise,” said Meitzen about learning of the ruling. “The possibility that this can make such a change for all of us who are affected by DOMA is just unbelievable.”

Bonauto said the case deals with the same “bread and butter issues” under review in Gill v. Office of Personnel Management. A federal appeals court in Boston ruled DOMA unconstitutional for the first time in Gill this past May, and both BLAG and the Department of Justice have filed petitions seeking Supreme Court review of that case. In total, one appellate court, five district courts, and onebankruptcy court have so far struck down DOMA on constitutional grounds.

While attorneys were still poring over the 104-page opinion from Bryant, Bonauto called the opinion “outstanding” in terms of its “big picture” and “granular” analysis. Bryant, a Queens, New York native, was the first African-American woman appointed a federal judge in New England.

Her opinion refutes point-by-point the arguments BLAG has used to argue that laws like DOMA which classify people based on sexual orientation should not be subjected to heightened scrutiny. In one part of the opinion, Bryant visits the issue of political power, where she rejects House Republicans’ arguments that gay men and lesbians do not hold a minority status in the country.

“BLAG has failed to demonstrate that the alleged ‘gay corporate power,’ the ability of gay men and lesbians to raise money for advocacy, or the election of fair-minded candidates in 2008 has actually translated into an ability to imminently end discrimination, prejudice and to prevent unfavorable outcomes such as Proposition 8 or ‘don’t say gay’ type legislation,” she writes.

“This is a very hefty opinion,” Bonauto told reporters on the conference call. “I have to say it was worth the wait on this one.”

BLAG is expected to appeal the decision in the Second Circuit. Meanwhile, GLAD plans to respond next month to the Supreme Court petition filed by the Justice Department in Gill. The steps increase the strong possibility that the high court will rule on the constitutionality of DOMA next year, although it is impossible to predict which cases the justices will agree to hear.

“We’re just going to be moving forward on multiple fronts,” said Bonauto. “It’s certainly not within our control what the Supreme Court is going to do. It certainly makes sense for us to continue moving forward to make sure Gill is fully briefed and in the meantime to proceed in the Second Circuit.”

BREAKING: Judge Rules DOMA Unconstitutional in Pedersen Case | Advocate.com.

Advertisements

11 comments on “BREAKING: Judge Rules DOMA Unconstitutional in Pedersen Case | Advocate.com

  • Enjoyed the post, I have a question, I’m looking for a good chiropractor because I need great one, I wanted reviews or feedback on Dynamic Health & Wellness 6119 Northwest Hwy # B Crystal Lake, IL 60014 (815) 356-6388

  • Thanks for another informative blog. Where else could I get that type of info written in such an ideal manner? I’ve a mission that I am just now working on, and I have been at the glance out for such info.

    • What is your mission? The article post was designed to get more people fighting for equal rights and remove DOMA from the federal level so that same sex marriage can be legalized in all 50 states.

  • Great submit, very informative. I’m wondering why the opposite specialists of this sector don’t notice this. You should continue your writing. I am confident, you have a huge readers’ base already!|What’s Going down i am new to this, I stumbled upon this I have discovered It absolutely helpful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to give a contribution & aid different users like its helped me. Good job.

  • Thanks a bunch for sharing this with all people you actually recognize what you are speaking approximately! Bookmarked. Kindly also visit my web site =). We can have a hyperlink trade arrangement between us

  • Leave a Reply

    Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

    Connecting to %s

    Ajah Dharma

    om... may the great spirit bless you

    What a Witch

    I am not nice, but I am honest and that is more important.

    Witches Of The Craft®

    "Witchcraft For The 21st Century"

    RealityShifters Blog

    Live your best possible life. How good can it get?

    Dear Cis People

    The ramblings of a non-binary Latino.

    moonshaman

    The realms of Spirit, Breath, Life ~ Shamanic Endeavors

    Stephanie Nicole

    Righteous Health

    Church of the Cosmos : Temple of Light

    WE ARE IMMORTAL TIMELESS BEINGS OF LIGHT IN AN INFINITELY EXPANDING OMNIVERSE FILLED WITH INTELLIGENT LIFE

    UMHS Gender Services

    comprehensive gender services program for gender variant people and their families

    DISMANTLE THE BEAM PROJECT

    Real conspiracies - all original content

    Mystery of the Iniquity

    Truth is inspiring, it is guarded by GOD, and will triumph over all opposition!

    wildeoats

    Quality gay-shaded & m/m stories, articles & art

    Josh Derke for State Representative

    Democrat for Michigan's 93rd House (2014)

    djmilosz

    Just another WordPress.com site

    Edge Induced Cohesion

    A Historian's Eye View of the World

    HandyBob's Blog

    Making off grid RV electrical systems work

    The Journey

    This WordPress.com site is the cat’s pajamas

    Daily Queer News

    LGBTI News and Politics

    evoL =

    Allies for equality.

    Finding my way back

    How do you cope with the loss?

    Mr. Moon's Meditation Chamber

    The Official Blog of Hip Hop Artist Tony Moon

    Different People

    Being gay with a mental illness(Bipolar) is a HUGE task to undertake!

    The Catbox

    Musings on modern Druidry in the UK

    The LGBT community and the journey ahead

    Being Gay is not a choice, we are born that way

    GAY MARRIAGE USA

    fb.com/GayMarriageUSA

    News and reviews

    sharing with others

    The Dream Faire

    Enchanted Jewelry Designs & Magical Creations by ♥Kat

    Gay Polyamory Blog

    My thoughts/adventures in polyamory and life.

    The Dark Bard

    Sharing my thoughts, and my soul, through the medium of poetry and prose.

    %d bloggers like this: